Welcome to Pizza 300
At Pizza 300, nestled in Newburgh, NY, the love for authentic pizza is palpable. With a commitment to crafting the perfect thin, crunchy crust, the pizzeria has gained a loyal following reminiscent of Brooklyn's finest. Customers rave about the ideal sauce-to-cheese ratio and the mouthwatering garlic knots, described as the best around. Highlights include a variety of pizzas, from classic pepperoni to gluten-free options, paired with delectable sides and chicken dishes that showcase an unparalleled culinary craft. With roots tracing back to renowned local establishments, Pizza 300 invites you to experience a slice of excellence that keeps patrons returning time and again.
Pizza 300: Reviews & Ratings
Best pizza in the 845 I love the thin crunchy crust with the perfect sauce to cheese ratio. It reminds of Brooklyn pizza. I can’t go wrong with a half plain / pepperoni, won’t disappoint!
No glaze pizza is good(personal pie) always ask for it crispy you moefoes
Absolute best garlic knots I've ever had! They are big, soft, and delicious! The pizza is delicious! We drive over 20 minutes to get this pizza because it is the best around! I love the crust, generous toppings, and overall a great experience. They have delicious gluten free pizza too! The staff is always so polite and offers to take the food out for you when it's a lot.
Wonderful! We tried 3 different pizza places and this one was our favorite! Getting into the parking lot was a bit tricky but worth it! We got a slice each and some garlic knots, fresh and flavorful. The restaurant and bathrooms were super clean! Definitely stopping again next time we're nearby!
Fabulous food! Sauce is excellent!! The best meatballs around!! Eggplant parm dinner was fantastic and the chicken marsala divine and are owned by Lou of Peppetini's & Storm King Fare Restaurants in Cornwall, NY which are exquisite Restaurants!!!! I'm so blessed to have Pizza 300 near my hacienda!!! I give this pizzeria ristorante 10 **********
Great pizza options (especially vegetarian) at this place. Service was excellent!
Salad was beautiful pizza was really good. Will be going again.
Secret little gem, hidden away in plain site. Their food is fresh made with the best ingredients available. We stopped one day out of curiosity, but what a find! Old is school tradition. Plain and simple if you grew up walking down the block and you stopped for a slice of pizza this is then place for you. It will bring you down Memory lane.
Location
-
1208 NY-300, Newburgh, NY 12550, United States Hotline: +1 845-561-6161
Welcome to the world of Pizza 300, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Newburgh, NY, at 1208 NY-300. Known for its exceptional menu, Pizza 300 has quickly established itself as a prime destination for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike. With a signature thin, crunchy crust that has been likened to the authentic flavors of Brooklyn, every pizza is a testament to culinary craftsmanship.
As you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza and savory entrees greets you. Customers rave about the perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio that ensures each slice is a delightful experience. Loyal patrons, like Ally, can't resist their classic half plain and pepperoni pizza, expressing that it simply doesn’t disappoint. The renowned garlic knots, praised by Melissa M for being the "absolute best," are another must-try item that reflects the restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients and hearty portions.
- Location: 1208 NY-300, Newburgh, NY 12550, United States
- Phone: +1 845-561-6161
- Highlights:
- Thin, crunchy crust pizza reminiscent of Brooklyn's classic style
- Exceptional garlic knots, described as big, soft, and delicious
- Wide range of entrees, including Eggplant Parmigiana and Sausage & Peppers
- Diverse pasta options, notably Stuffed Shells and Baked Ziti
- Accommodating staff that enhances the dining experience
Beyond pizza, the menu boasts an impressive selection of entrees and pasta, including the delightful eggplant parmigiana that has captured the hearts of many. As diaminlil noted, the sauce is simply excellent, further enhancing the flavors of their top-rated meatballs. The extensive pasta offerings—like Penne Alla Vodka and Ravioli—ensure that there’s something for everyone, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings or a casual night out.
Though the parking may be a slight challenge, as Monica O pointed out, it is certainly worth the effort for the freshly crafted, flavorful dishes and the charming ambiance that Pizza 300 has to offer. So, whether you’re a local or just passing through, make it a point to indulge in the culinary wonders that Pizza 300 serves up. You won’t regret the journey for a slice of their remarkable pizza, which has garnered glowing reviews and a loyal customer base.